Quantcast

Remembering The Golden Rule

posted on 1/5/10 by Nancy Lyons

Everyone learns the Golden Rule at some point in their childhood.  You know it - treat others the way you'd want to be treated.  Or, simply put, treat people with consideration.  It's one of those basic human values that is shared by Christians, Buddhists, Muslims and Humanists.  The Golden Rule is one of ethics and humanity, more than anything else.  We need to choose, every day, to be decent to one another.  And, surprisingly, it's not always so easy to do.  Being human is just hard.  These days, with business and information moving at the speed of sound, and everyone trying to keep up with the Joneses or bubble up or be remarkable or be a 'thought leader' humanity takes even more of a back seat. Most of the time, that's really not the intent. Social Media can be a channel for self promotion.  And when we're too self-focused we lose site of each other and, by extension, we lose sight of that Golden Rule. 

Over the holiday my house was bustling with family and festivities.  My sister (who has no idea I'm using her for this post and hopefully she won't care) stayed with us to celebrate Christmas.  We were busy - a big family gathering on Christmas Eve.  Friends in town and staying over with us for Christmas morning.  My three-year-old was enjoying the first Christmas where he really embraced the magic of Santa Claus.  The last thing I was thinking about was what sorts of images of me might end up on the Internet.  I was wrapping up work, and cleaning my house, and preparing hor d'oeuvres and doing last minute shopping and, you name it - it was on my list.  By the time Christmas morning rolled around I was breathing a sigh of relief at the prospect of a nap.  Now, I don't know about you, but I do not sleep in what one would refer to as high fashion.  In fact, I'll admit it, my night-time wardrobe has been sorely neglected over the years and most every morning, when I come plodding out of my bedroom sporting a brilliant case of bedhead and some misguided combination of sweatpants and a t-shirt, I look positively homeless.  Christmas morning was no exception.  I played spectator to my son and the Christmas motherlode.  I completely missed the fact that I was a passive participant in a series of photographs capturing his excitement.  There I was looking like a bloated, homeless whale - laying on the couch or curled up on the floor or all contorted for some crazy task with 'some assembly required'.  My sister, whom I adore, was capturing every precious moment of my baby's magical morning.  Unfortunately, my butt was the backdrop for a good number of those moments and I had no idea.  No idea, that is, until my butt showed up on Facebook. 

Facebook, the basement-home-movies-and-instantaneous-scrapbook all rolled into one.  Instead of inviting your friends over to bore them with your latest adventure as you project your vacation slides on your paneled rec-room wall, just share your family fun on Facebook and they can comment and 'Like' your life from anywhere, right this instant, and forever.  Somewhere between brunch and my long winter's nap on Christmas Day I logged into Facebook to kill some time and was immediately notified that my sister had posted some pictures.  My heart raced as I quickly reviewed her recently uploaded collection.  Granted, I wasn't the focal point of any of those photos.  But, it could not be denied, that there I was, looking about as comfortable and unkempt as a person ever should, right smack dap in the middle of my sister's 'wall'.  I thought very seriously about the correct response to this issue.  On the one hand, they were not my pictures and my sister can take and post whatever she wants on her Facebook page.  But on the other hand, about 25 of her friends are my 'friends' and I wasn't entirely comfortable with anyone, save my immediate family, seeing me in such a state.  It's an interesting dilemma when you think about it.  Social Media only works when the intent and the content is authentic.  One could argue that my desire to remove pictures of myself looking terrifying is not exactly authentic.  But I also need to feel safe in my own house.  I need to know I can roam around in my underwear and not have to worry about it showing up on the world wide web by nightfall.  Who is deciding how these things work?  We are.  And, quite honestly, there's nothing all that digital or 'new' about it.  When thinking about how best to be 'social' in the Social Media sphere, remember the Golden Rule.  Treat others the way you would like to be treated.  Show them some consideration. 

Now, I'm not suggesting my sis had any ill intentions in posting those photos.  I think she simply wanted to share the images of her sweet nephew's holiday excitement.  But without my consent, or prior review, she was sharing much more than that.  You see the moral dilemma?  What right did I have to ask her to edit what she wanted to share with her network?  The problem was, once the content was tagged, it was shareable outside of her network.  And I have no idea what her privacy settings look like.  Bottom line - I was not comfortable with it.  It wasn't about oversharing - it was about my level of comfort with what was being shared.  The Geek Girls have said time and time again, behind every picture is the human that took it and posted it.  If you don't like the picture talk to the human.  I mean, come on.  In this new era of immediacy in communication - we have to all commit to being reasonable when publishing content to what is really a GLOBAL network.  But I say we should go a step further and, as creators of content, we need to apply the Golden Rule.  We need to be sensitive to and considerate of others first.  Ask before you post if there is anything that could be even slightly compromising.  I don't think that asking for a little kindness is really asking for all that much.  In fact, that is exactly what I asked of my sister -- I asked her to be kind to me in re-reviewing those pictures.  In the end, she was more than kind and for that I am grateful.

Go ahead - post your pictures, share your videos - put it all out there.  But before you hit 'submit' - remember the moral of this story - remember the Golden Rule.  Be kind to each other.

Post a comment:
10 Comments:
10 Comment:
Comments:
(1) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
This media is so new to so many that they've never even considered the impact of what they share. Hopefully with time, people will start thinking before they post.
(2) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
Thank you for posting this story! I was recently in a similar dilemma. During a camping trip with 3 families, we celebrated the birthdays of three of us who all had birthdays that weekend. I want to emphasize that I was camping. No make-up, no shower. Someone brought a cake and lined us up for the usual birthday photo. My good friend, also a birthday girl, posted the lovely close-up of the three of us on her site. Yes, it was HER FB page, but I looked like death warmed over. We share many FB friends including some that are work colleagues of mine. This was not a photo I would want to anyone. Asking if she could remove it or crop me out was very uncomfortable, and I sensed some resentment from her. She's thin & naturally beautiful, and I don't think she knows how hard some of us work to just look acceptable. It's still an uncomfortable topic between us today. It's also made me much more sensitive to the fact that you always have to put your best face forward in more than once sense! Thanks for sharing your story. It's nice to know I'm not alone in my feelings about this.
(3) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
Thanks for sharing Nancy. Perhaps Facebook needs to develop a system to allow users to gently request take-downs of images of themselves... sure one can un-tag themself but the management of the image remains in hands of of poster. In fun but complex times we live.
(4) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
I agree with Andrew. It would also be a helpful feature to use when a well-intentioned friend posts pictures on a social networking site of your child (a minor), at an event you were not at and did not know about. In their enthusiasm to show how much fun everyone was having, they often forget to ask a parent's permission before posting the pictures. Innocent enough photos, but logging on to FB is not a good way of being informed. (BTW, I apologize to anyone to whom I might have done this!)
(5) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
This post is a much needed reminder. I'm constantly whipping out my camera and I do post photos daily to flickr and sometimes to Facebook. But I try to remain mindful about my subjects. I have a pretty good sense of who is camera shy, who is a total ham (like many of my lovely co-workers at Clockwork, aka Clockworkers) and where some fall anywhere in between. I try to err on the side of caution when deciding which shots to post. But it's been trial and error over the years. Because of my height - or lack of it - some friends and family have begged me to stand on a chair and shoot from above to avoid giving them the appearance of extra chins. I am happy to comply. And naturally I prefer to be on the shooting side of the camera.
(6) On January 6, 2010, Author Editor says:
Nancy, this is a terrific post, and we all should be mindful of what we expose about others in our social networks. I remember years ago a website called "fugly.com" (I hope it doesn't still exist,) used to re-post unflattering pictures of people found online, along with very mean captions. I'd hate to find a picture of myself on a site like that - and yes, I am certain there are many pictures of me that would be good candidates.

In my own Facebook privacy settings, I limit visibility of my photos to "Only Friends, " but I wonder what happens if a friend, tagged in my picture, has settings which say "Photos Tagged of Me" are visible to "Everybody." Which rule takes precedence? In other words, I not only do not know my friends' privacy settings, I don't really understand what they would accomplish, either.

Probably best, as you say, to always "do unto others." After all, I know I can't teach my mom how Facebook privacy rules work, but I my mom has already taught me good manners!
(7) On January 7, 2010, Author Editor says:
Totally agree, Nancy. Your line "need to feel safe in my own home" says it all. Beyond the loss of control you felt with yourself, though, you also lost control of images of your child.

I have a steadfast rule - I NEVER post pictures of someone else's kid on Facebook. (And really, their house, or unflattering pictures would fall into this same category.)

While it's so easy to feel safe and comfortable within the confines of your Facebook network, and with very good intentions want so share precious moments with your friends and family, bottom line is, you are still posting other people's private lives on the INTERNET. And, like you said, once tagged, you've essentially robbed those people of their own privacy.

Most often, it's all with the best intentions, and simply a matter of the guilty party not even realizing the ramifications of their actions. Thank you, as always, for bringing the issue to light.
(8) On January 7, 2010, Author Editor says:
In the middle of this very funny post is a very valuable lesson. And, I think, until it happens to each of us, we don't really think about how what we post affects the other person (or people).

I recently had a situation where a friend took a picture of herself and a mutual friend of ours. She tagged them both in the photo, as well as me, so I would see it. He untagged himself and never offered a reason why. It wasn't an unflattering photo. It was at a business event. We still don't know why he untagged himself, because he refuses to talk about it.

So your lesson about remembering the Golden Rule goes both ways (and, if you watch "How I Met Your Mother", this is not to be confused with The Platinum Rule).
(9) On January 7, 2010, Author Editor says:
The human eye contains one million nerve endings http://squ1.org/wiki/human_eye; I think another popular saying, "Seeing is Believing," should be well considered when posting photos/videos. My husband closed his facebook account because he did not want everyone to share in every family event being posted online. Thank You for sharing your story. Karen
(10) On January 23, 2010, Author Editor says:
I posted a group photo of myself with friends on FB, and one friend asked me to remove it since she'd lost a noticeable amount of weight since the picture was taken. Although I thought the picture was fine, I took it down. The friendship matters more.